Home › Sold Homes › Stillwater
Homes Sold in Stillwater, PA
31 closed sales on record, 9 of them in the last 24 months. Newest first.
Sold
$647,000
63 Whispering Pines Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
2 bd2 ba1,728 sf
Sold March 2026 · MLS # 25-3240
Sold
$275,000
78 Whispering Pines Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba1,875 sf
Sold January 2026 · MLS # 25-5826
Sold
$365,000
163 Karns Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17874
2 bd1 ba1,446 sf
Sold December 2025 · MLS # 25-5391
Sold
$185,500
263 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba1,316 sf
Sold November 2025 · MLS # 25-5688
Sold
$255,000
575 Paperdale Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,248 sf
Sold September 2025 · MLS # 25-4236
Sold
$55,000
Route 239, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4.38 ac
Sold July 2025 · MLS # 25-2603
Sold
$91,000
1476 N Bendertown Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
Sold June 2025 · MLS # 25-2161
Sold
$399,900
41 Blueberry Lane, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba2,092 sf
Sold November 2024 · MLS # 24-5829
Sold
$161,500
1357 Old Tioga, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba2,145 sf
Sold November 2024 · MLS # 24-4793
Sold
$95,500
79 Cemetery Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
1,920 sf
Sold September 2024 · MLS # 24-3884
Sold
$230,000
236 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,881 sf
Sold May 2024 · MLS # 24-2440
Sold
$143,500
1360 Old Tioga, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba1,600 sf
Sold February 2023 · MLS # 23-587
Sold
$378,000
81 Three Springs Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba2,318 sf
Sold July 2022 · MLS # 22-2542
Sold
$272,000
468 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,148 sf
Sold September 2021 · MLS # 21-3673
Sold
$20,000
1361 Old Tioga, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,416 sf
Sold January 2021 · MLS # 20-909
Sold
$31,000
3917 Maple Grove Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
2 bd1 ba768 sf
Sold December 2020 · MLS # 20-1722
Sold
$381,000
110 Beaver Dam Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd3 ba2,084 sf
Sold November 2020 · MLS # 20-5158
Sold
$178,000
484 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,632 sf
Sold August 2020 · MLS # 20-2227
Sold
$32,000
173 Pine Creek Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4.43 ac
Sold April 2020 · MLS # 20-670
Sold
$220,000
110 Valley View Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd3 ba1,585 sf
Sold January 2020 · MLS # 19-4046
Sold
$220,000
105 Valley View Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba1,196 sf
Sold August 2019 · MLS # 19-2410
Sold
$115,000
1644 N BENDERTOWN Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,588 sf
Sold August 2018 · MLS # 18-3116
Sold
$150,000
144 Beaver Dam Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,040 sf
Sold June 2018 · MLS # 17-2231
Sold
$227,900
873 Bonnieville, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
5 bd3 ba2,888 sf
Sold October 2017 · MLS # 17-2343
Sold
$216,000
299 Zackery, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba2,050 sf
Sold July 2017 · MLS # 17-2443
Sold
$175,000
41 Sunny Slope Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,040 sf
Sold June 2017 · MLS # 17-2822
Sold
$61,250
3992 Maple Grove Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba2,040 sf
Sold April 2017 · MLS # 17-470
Sold
$49,000
41 Sunny Slope Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,040 sf
Sold October 2016 · MLS # 16-5279
Sold
$12,500
Weaver Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
1.5 ac
Sold December 2015 · MLS # 15-4319
Sold
163 Academy Street, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba960 sf
Sold November 2012 · MLS # 12-978
Sold
1857 PA-239, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,232 sf
Sold May 2012 · MLS # 11-3414
Based on information from the Luzerne County Association of REALTORS® MLS as of October 15, 2026.
What’s Your Stillwater Home Worth?
Recent sales like this one set the price for homes in Stillwater. Tell us about your property and we’ll put together a market analysis built on verified comparable sales.
Request a Valuation