Home › Sold Homes › Stillwater

Homes Sold in Stillwater, PA

31 closed sales on record, 9 of them in the last 24 months. Newest first.
Sold
$647,000
63 Whispering Pines Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
2 bd2 ba1,728 sf
Sold March 2026 · MLS # 25-3240
Sold
$275,000
78 Whispering Pines Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba1,875 sf
Sold January 2026 · MLS # 25-5826
Sold
$365,000
163 Karns Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17874
2 bd1 ba1,446 sf
Sold December 2025 · MLS # 25-5391
Sold
$185,500
263 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba1,316 sf
Sold November 2025 · MLS # 25-5688
Sold
$255,000
575 Paperdale Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,248 sf
Sold September 2025 · MLS # 25-4236
Sold
$55,000
Route 239, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4.38 ac
Sold July 2025 · MLS # 25-2603
Sold
$91,000
1476 N Bendertown Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
Sold June 2025 · MLS # 25-2161
Sold
$399,900
41 Blueberry Lane, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba2,092 sf
Sold November 2024 · MLS # 24-5829
Sold
$161,500
1357 Old Tioga, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba2,145 sf
Sold November 2024 · MLS # 24-4793
Sold
$95,500
79 Cemetery Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
1,920 sf
Sold September 2024 · MLS # 24-3884
Sold
$230,000
236 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,881 sf
Sold May 2024 · MLS # 24-2440
Sold
$143,500
1360 Old Tioga, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba1,600 sf
Sold February 2023 · MLS # 23-587
Sold
$378,000
81 Three Springs Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba2,318 sf
Sold July 2022 · MLS # 22-2542
Sold
$272,000
468 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,148 sf
Sold September 2021 · MLS # 21-3673
Sold
$20,000
1361 Old Tioga, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,416 sf
Sold January 2021 · MLS # 20-909
Sold
$31,000
3917 Maple Grove Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
2 bd1 ba768 sf
Sold December 2020 · MLS # 20-1722
Sold
$381,000
110 Beaver Dam Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd3 ba2,084 sf
Sold November 2020 · MLS # 20-5158
Sold
$178,000
484 Bonnieville Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,632 sf
Sold August 2020 · MLS # 20-2227
Sold
$32,000
173 Pine Creek Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4.43 ac
Sold April 2020 · MLS # 20-670
Sold
$220,000
110 Valley View Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd3 ba1,585 sf
Sold January 2020 · MLS # 19-4046
Sold
$220,000
105 Valley View Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba1,196 sf
Sold August 2019 · MLS # 19-2410
Sold
$115,000
1644 N BENDERTOWN Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,588 sf
Sold August 2018 · MLS # 18-3116
Sold
$150,000
144 Beaver Dam Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,040 sf
Sold June 2018 · MLS # 17-2231
Sold
$227,900
873 Bonnieville, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
5 bd3 ba2,888 sf
Sold October 2017 · MLS # 17-2343
Sold
$216,000
299 Zackery, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd3 ba2,050 sf
Sold July 2017 · MLS # 17-2443
Sold
$175,000
41 Sunny Slope Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,040 sf
Sold June 2017 · MLS # 17-2822
Sold
$61,250
3992 Maple Grove Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
4 bd2 ba2,040 sf
Sold April 2017 · MLS # 17-470
Sold
$49,000
41 Sunny Slope Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd1 ba1,040 sf
Sold October 2016 · MLS # 16-5279
Sold
$12,500
Weaver Road, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
1.5 ac
Sold December 2015 · MLS # 15-4319
Sold
163 Academy Street, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba960 sf
Sold November 2012 · MLS # 12-978
Sold
1857 PA-239, Stillwater
Stillwater, PA 17878
3 bd2 ba1,232 sf
Sold May 2012 · MLS # 11-3414

What Is Your Stillwater Home Worth?

Recent sales like this one set the price for homes in Stillwater. One of our agents will review them and prepare a valuation for your home.

Request a Valuation