557 Milwaukee Avenue, Old Forge

Old Forge, PA, 18518 · MLS #26-1280

$253,001

Sold May 2026

557 Milwaukee Avenue, Old Forge in Old Forge

1 / 8

Approximate location · View larger map

Beds

Baths

1,344

Interior SF

780

Basement SF

$188

Per Sq Ft

Last List Price

$239,900

Sold For

$253,001

Against Asking

Sold 5.5% above asking

Thinking about selling in Old Forge? Find out what your home is worth, based on recent sales like this one.

About This Property

Tucked away in the Pizza Capital of the World, this quaint three-bedroom, two-bath home is full of potential and ready for its next chapter. Step inside to find a spacious layout with great bones and plenty of natural light throughout. The main living areas offer a comfortable flow, perfect for everyday living or entertaining. Downstairs, the finished lower level adds valuable extra living space and features a convenient kitchenette--ideal for guests, extended family, or a cozy hangout area. With a little vision and your personal finishing touches, this home can truly shine. Enjoy the charm of a sought-after location known for its rich history, local favorites, and close proximity to shops, dining, and major roadways. Come see the possibilities for yourself!

This property has sold and is no longer on the market. It sold for $253,001 in May 2026. Contact us for other recent sales nearby. Listed by Jonathan J. Nelson Real Estate.

Property Details

The Property

Property Type: Residential
Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Condition: Very Good
Levels: Bi-Level
Total Rooms: 10

Interior

Finished Above Grade: 1,344 sq ft
Finished Below Grade: 780 sq ft
Basement: Finished, Standard Entry Door
Fireplaces: 1
Interior Features: Eat-in Kitchen
Included: All existing kitchen appliances.

Systems

Heating: Electric, Baseboard
Cooling: Ductless
Water: Public
Sewer: Public Sewer

Exterior & Lot

Exterior: Brick, Aluminum Siding
Roof: Composition
Outdoor: Patio
Garage: 2 Car Attached
Parking: Private
Lot Dimensions: 150x80

Location

County: Lackawanna County
School District: Old Forge

Costs & Listing

Annual Taxes: $5,307
MLS #: 26-1280
Listed By: Jonathan J. Nelson Real Estate

What’s Your Old Forge Home Worth?

Recent sales like this one set the price for homes in Old Forge. Tell us about your property and we’ll put together a market analysis built on verified comparable sales.

Request a Valuation

Our Team

16 TEAM MEMBERS.

Serving all of Northeastern Pennsylvania · Meet the team →